The Premier Guide to Pizza in Columbus

Columbus, Ohio, has a diverse and rich pizza landscape, reflecting its cosmopolitan populace and culinary creativity. This guide aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the finest pizza establishments the city has to offer. From traditional pies reminiscent of New York’s classic slices to innovative creations that push the boundaries of what pizza can be, Columbus is a city that both preserves and reinvents this beloved dish.

Harvest Pizzeria

Harvest Pizzeria excels in offering a genuine Neapolitan pizza experience, emphasizing organic, locally sourced ingredients and traditional methods. Their pizzas are a testament to the beauty of simplicity, featuring light, airy crusts with a delightful char, thanks to their wood-fired ovens. The use of San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella provides a base that is both flavorful and authentic. Beyond the classics, their innovative toppings cater to a modern palate, making Harvest a beacon for those who appreciate both tradition and culinary creativity in pizza making.

Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza

Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza is renowned for capturing the essence of traditional New York pizza right in the heart of Columbus. What sets Adriatico’s apart is their commitment to quality, using only the freshest ingredients to top their notably large, thin, and crispy slices. The robust flavor of their tomato sauce paired with generous toppings and a perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio creates a satisfying and authentic New York-style experience. Ideal for both a quick lunch or a large gathering, Adriatico’s delivers consistency and taste that has cultivated a loyal following.

Paulie Gee’s Short North

Paulie Gee’s Short North stands out in the Columbus pizza scene for its daring and inventive approach to pizza. This pizzeria is a haven for food enthusiasts looking to explore unique flavor combinations, such as incorporating spicy honey or house-made vegan sausage into their dishes. The ambiance of the place, coupled with their friendly service, makes dining here a delightful experience. Paulie Gee’s commitment to both quality and creativity makes each pizza a culinary adventure, pushing the boundaries of traditional pizza while respecting its origins.

Borgata Pizza Café

Borgata Pizza Café offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere that complements its menu perfectly, specializing in a fusion of Sicilian-inspired thick crust pizzas with Midwestern generosity in toppings. Their homemade ingredients, like sausage and meatballs, are standout features that elevate their pizzas above standard fare. Borgata’s commitment to homemade, hearty food at reasonable prices has made it a cherished spot among locals, providing a blend of comfort and quality that’s hard to find elsewhere.

Tommy’s Pizza

Tommy’s Pizza is a Columbus institution, known for a distinctive style that melds the heartiness of Chicago deep-dish with the practicality of traditional Columbus pizza. Their crust is uniquely flaky and buttery, supporting layers of rich cheese and dense toppings. Tommy’s has mastered the art of deep-dish pizza in a way that doesn’t just fill the stomach but also delights the palate. Loyal customers and newcomers alike frequent Tommy’s for a taste of this local legacy, enjoying both the food and the warm, nostalgic setting.

Mikey’s Late Night Slice

Mikey’s Late Night Slice has become synonymous with Columbus’s vibrant nightlife, offering an eclectic and funky spot where pizza lovers can grab a slice well into the wee hours. Known for their cheeky humor and inventive toppings, their pies are large, cheesy, and always served with a side of their signature “unicorn sauce.” The environment is casual and decidedly fun, making it a popular choice for both locals and visitors looking to satisfy late-night cravings with quality pizza that’s both delicious and memorable.

Ange’s Pizza

Ange’s Pizza, a family-run establishment since the 1950s, boasts a loyal customer base thanks to its secret recipe sauce and homemade dough. What sets Ange’s apart is their dedication to tradition and consistency, offering a pizza that’s both comfortingly familiar and exceptionally tasty. Their hand-tossed pizzas are known for a perfectly balanced crust that’s neither too thick nor too thin, topped with generous amounts of cheese and fresh toppings. Ange’s remains a staple in the community for those seeking an authentic, no-frills pizza experience.

Rubino’s Pizza

Rubino’s Pizza, a staple in the Bexley area since 1954, sticks to a simple, time-tested formula that has captivated generations. Known for its thin crust and minimalistic approach to toppings, Rubino’s offers a crisp, almost cracker-like base that highlights the savory flavor of their traditional sauce and quality ingredients. This spot is a must-visit for those who appreciate a pizza that focuses on quality over quantity, where every bite speaks of its heritage and dedication to old-world craftsmanship.

GoreMade Pizza

GoreMade Pizza offers a distinct take on the wood-fired style, where each pie is crafted with ingredients sourced from local farms and suppliers. This commitment to local sourcing not only supports the community but also ensures that each pizza is a reflection of Ohio’s seasonal best. The outdoor seating and live music events add to its charm, making it an inviting space for family and friends to gather and enjoy artisanal pizzas that burst with fresh, vibrant flavors.

Pizza Cottage

Pizza Cottage stands out for its family-friendly atmosphere and a broad menu that caters to all tastes, including a range of appetizers, subs, and, of course, pizzas. Their commitment to quality is evident in their use of premium ingredients and handmade dough, prepared fresh daily. Pizza Cottage is particularly beloved for its buffet, which allows diners to sample a wide variety of pizza styles and toppings. It’s an ideal spot for those who enjoy a casual dining experience coupled with the comfort of hearty, well-made pizza.

Mellow Mushroom

Mellow Mushroom brings a unique, artistic flair to the Columbus pizza scene, combining a vibrant, psychedelic decor with an extensive menu of gourmet pizzas. Known for their stone-baked crusts and creative use of fresh, often unusual ingredients, Mellow Mushroom offers a culinary experience that’s as visually engaging as it is delicious. Their commitment to high-quality food extends to offering a variety of vegan and gluten-free options, making it a welcoming place for diners with diverse dietary preferences. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Margherita or something more adventurous like the Thai Dye pizza, Mellow Mushroom delivers with style and taste.


Whether your preference lies with the thin crust and tangy sauce of a New York-style slice or the rich, deep-dish pies that characterize Chicago, Columbus’s pizza scene offers something to satisfy every palate. As the city continues to grow and evolve, so too does its array of pizzerias. New styles emerge, but the love for well-crafted pizza remains constant. Next time you’re in Columbus, let your taste buds explore these exceptional pizzerias and discover why this city might just be one of the best places for pizza aficionados.

Leave a Comment